Is this the same man? What's going on? 1841

[Nell]

I know 1841 doesn't give relationships and ages aren't accurate, which isn't much help, but I'm puzzled.

Ex's gt x 3 grandparents were John & Frances Goodwin.
They had these children baptised St Giles in the Fields:
John 1814
George 1816
Harriet 1818
Thomas 1820
Sarah 1822
3 younger children's baptisms not found - they are Charles b 1826, Elizabeth Alice b abt 1830 and William b 1831.

I've found John & Frances in 1841 here with youngest sons Charles & William.
John Goodwin is 50.

Class: HO107; Piece 670; Book: 4; Civil Parish: St Andrew Holb
orn (Above The Bars); County: Middlesex; Enumeration District: 11; Folio: 48; Page: 14
http://search.ancestry.co.uk/iexec/?htx=view&r=5538&dbid=8978&iid=MDXHO107_668_670-0599&fn=John&ln=Goodwin&st=d&ssrc=&pid=7141282

but looking for other children I found a Thomas (age slightly out as it was in 1841)

I found this household:

HO107; Piece 673; Book: 7; Civil Parish: St Giles in The Fields; County: Middlesex; Enumeration District: 7; Folio: 14; Page: 21
http://search.ancestry.co.uk/iexec/?htx=view&r=5538&dbid=8978&iid=MDXHO107_672_673-0506&fn=Thomas&ln=Goodwin&st=r&ssrc=&pid=7183795

Thomas isn't exactly the right age, but the address is Great Wild Street, which is the address on the baptisms of John & Frances' children.
And on the previous page is John Goodwin aged 50!
Unfortunately the images are faded and there doesn't appear to be any occupations given either.

Any ideas?

[kiterunner]

The woman's name looks like Sarah 50 and the children Amelia 8, Thomas 15, Charles 6, but it's really difficult to make out.

[Nell]

I've got the names, KiteRunner, thanks for looking. Just not sure if John is Sarah's and a different chap to my John and the address and name of Thomas is a coincidence, or whether there's a bit of bigamy going on or what!

Can't find a baptism for Amelia either. The Johns can't be brothers.

[Nell]

bumping in case anyone has any theories - is it the same John Goodwin?